David Moyes has some big decisions ahead. Surely he will have licence to make at least one major transfer this summer, or two to three more subtle acquisitions. Let’s consider where the Scot may look to strengthen, and how United may shape up come August.
Defence:
It seems De Gea has come through the media scrutiny and tumultuous screening process at United, and with some further work on his strength and decision making he will become one of the best keepers around. As it stands, he is already a world-class shot stopper with impressive agility and reactions. Rafael still poses question marks after his best season at Old Trafford, not in terms of his promising ability, but rather the immature behaviour which saw him lash out at David Luiz at the end of the season. Moyes seems the right man to discipline and guide Rafael, and to ensure his tenacity and aggression is honed in to an asset rather than a flaw.
This season may be the one where Phil Jones cements his position as first choice centre back. With Ferdinand and Vidic past their physical peaks, and with a slowly emerging Chris Smalling, Jones could find himself becoming the more consistent option for Moyes. The former Toffees boss generally favours a consistent pairing than rotation, with Jagielka and Distin (occasionally Heitinga) forming a solid backbone for the blues. Jonny Evans rarely lets you down, so don’t count against the Northern Irishman becoming Mr.Dependable under Moyes.
Evra and Buttner offer plenty at left back, yet rumors of Evra’s return to Ligue 1 persist, in which case Leighton Baines appears a natural successor. Buttner looks promising enough that United need not spend big to lure Luke Shaw from Southampton, and the young Dutchman should push his competition further this year.
Midfield:
United have options, but much depends on the formation Moyes opts for, and on the potential outgoings this summer. Michael Carrick has had his best ever season, and every indication is that the Englishman’s fluid passes and adept positioning will continue to grace the centre midfield. Who Carrick’s partner will be remains a much speculated-upon topic, which suggests that Tom Cleverley’s stellar efforts may not have been enough to cement his place thus far. Target Cesc Fabregas would have been ideal alongside Carrick, yet he is staying put. Everyone from Marco Verrati to Luka Modric has been mentioned, and United fans have yearned for a real box-to-box centre midfielder for some time. Thiago Alcantara’s arrival would suggest a 4-3-3 for United, and it seems feasible that Marouane Fellaini and Yohan Cabaye remain realistic possibilities. If United are to play a 4-2-3-1, they are perhaps in need of a more defensively astute but versatile midfielder, such as a Sami Khedira, Arturo Vidal, or Ilkay Gundogan. Yet all of the above (with the exception of Cabaye) would come at a relatively hefty price. Much depends on Moyes’ vision. United might well surprise us again, and take a risk on someone like Marco van Ginkel, who could be a promising long-term option.
Out wide, United have many options, but perhaps lack consistent, proven quality. Shinji Kagawa is world-class, yet all indications are that he is a much greater player when restored to the no.10 role where he made his name, rather than a wide left role. That being said, Kagawa offers versatility, skill and diligence, and is sure to be a fixture in Moyes’ plans, whichever role he ends up with. Wilfried Zaha set the Championship alight last year, and very much looks to have been a shrewd signing. Ashley Young, Nani and Valencia seem to lack the X factor, and unless they step up, Moyes may, like Ferguson, occasionally prefer Welbeck out wide, who offers endeavour, pace and goals.
Attack:
RVP is very much the MVP at United. It seems he will flourish best in a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1, which perhaps means more frustration for Welbeck, Rooney, Hernandez and co.
Hernandez is surprisingly content at the Red Devils, and is as good an auxiliary forward as one can hope to have. Welbeck’s versatility should see him play a fair portion of games, however Moyes’ biggest issue concerns another England striker. Rooney would surely have a role as no.10 in a United 4-2-3-1, or a wide role in a 4-3-3, however every indication seems to be that he wants that central role, and United seem less keen on a 4-4-2 that would give him that chance alongside RVP.
It seems that Moyes has a real job on his hands if he is to keep United’s current batch happy, yet there are positive indications in that United appear to be only a couple of players away from another potentially league-winning side. Yohan Cabaye or Marco van Ginkel would provide versatility and box-to-box ability for between £9-12m, cheaper than an Alcantara, Fellaini or Modric, and perhaps better equipped to United’s needs. Leighton Baines seems too good a fit not to be in red come August; he has the passion, professionalism and class to be a real success and fan favourite, and Monaco’s bid for Evra would probably match Baines’ cost. Two instances of astute business, and some of that classic Moyes mentality, and I’m confident that United will continue to be a real force. Here’s a guess as to how they may line up, or improve:
4-2-3-1
De Gea
Rafael Jones Vidic Baines
Carrick Cleverley (or Cabaye/van Ginkel)
Young/Welbeck Rooney Kagawa/Zaha
Van Persie
or a 4-3-3 with
De Gea
Rafael Jones Vidic Baines
Cleverley Carrick Cabaye/van Ginkel
Rooney/Welbeck RvP Kagawa